Sit/Start Week 2: Reviewing All the Fantasy Relevant Players In Every Single Game

The QB List staff helps you make your sit/start decisions for every Week 2 game.

Patriots at Dolphins

 

Game Info

Kickoff: Sunday, September 15th at 1:00 pm EST

Location: Hard Rock Stadium, Miami Gardens, FL

Betting Odds: MIA +19, via Oddsshark

Network: CBS

Sleeper Spotlight: Preston Williams

 

New England Patriots

 

Quarterbacks

  • Tom Brady (Start/QB1)

 

Tom Brady did what Tom Brady does Week 1 against the Steelers – dominate. This isn’t easy for me to praise given my Jets fandom, but Brady simply does not miss. He carved up the Pittsburgh defense for 341 yards, three touchdowns, and zero interceptions; all to the tune of a 124.9 QBR. This week, he faces a Miami defense that had a laughable opener, losing to Baltimore 59-10. Look for Brady to have a strong game yet again, especially since he’s been gifted with another weapon to work with.

 

Running Backs

  • James White (Start/RB2)
  • Sony Michel (Start/Flex)
  • Rex Burkhead (Sit)

 

As it has been for years now, the New England backfield is crowded, and never clear as to who’s the go-to choice. Last week, Sony Michel led the team with 15 carries, but only posted 14 yards. Chances have you drafted him decently early, and so you’ll want him in your lineup, even if it’s in your FLEX. Rex Burkhead followed with eight rushes for 44 yards, and five receptions for 41 yards, though my claim to sit him is simply a guesstimate of how the backfield will play out. James White only had four carries for 26 yards to pair with his five receptions for 56 yards. Brady tends to favor White heavily in the passing game, and when he gets going, he’s usually a pivotal part to the offensive gameplan. I’d slot him in as an RB2 in what could be another high scoring affair against the Dolphins defense.

 

Wide Receivers/Tight Ends

  • Julian Edelman (Start/WR1)
  • Josh Gordon (Start/FLEX)
  • Phillip Dorsett (Start/FLEX)
  • Antonio Brown (?/likely sit)

 

No surprise here; you’re going to want some stock in the Patriots WR’s this week. Julian Edelman is a no-brainer WR1. Both Josh Gordon and Phillip Dorsett should be viable FLEX options. While Dorsett did score twice (with ease) against the Steelers, it’s never given how the target share will end up for the NE receivers from week to week.

 

I have Antonio Brown with a question mark because his situation is truly uncertain heading into this game. He may very well be active, but will he be on a pitch count? Will recent (as of writing this) legal accusations play into his game-time status throughout the week? I firmly believe you cannot consider starting him until he logs practices, and receives some praise from Belichick. If you drafted AB, you’ve likely held onto him in hopes of him showing up for Oakland, or landed elsewhere. Well, you got the latter, but I would wait to feature him in your lineup until he’s showcased in reality.

 

Miami Dolphins

 

Quarterbacks

  • Ryan Fitzpatrick (Sit)

 

Last season, Ryan Fitzpatrick was a top fantasy option early on for the Buccaneers, given the offense in front of him. However now in Miami, it’s nowhere near as potent. Fitzpatrick only completed 14 of 29 attempts for 185 yards and a score, with one INT to boot against the Ravens. I wouldn’t recommend starting him this week.

 

Running Backs

  • Kenyan Drake (Sit)
  • Kalen Ballage (Sit)

 

Let the sit list grow. I’m not starting either Dolphin running back here; Kenyan Drake nor Kalen Ballage. Ballage was receiving more praise this summer over Drake, and although the Miami offense overall did nothing against Baltimore, Ballage did not help his case at all. He somehow managed to have five carries net -1 yard on the ground. Drake had a sad four carries go for 12 yards. I’m not looking for either of them to get going against New England, who last week held James Conner to just 21 yards on ten carries.

 

Wide Receivers/Tight Ends

  • DeVante Parker (FLEX)
  • Preston Williams (FLEX – deeper leagues/sleeper candidate)
  • Mike Gesicki (TE – deeper leagues)

 

I say this with all due respect – FLEX DeVante Parker if you must. Same goes for Mike Gesicki if you’re in a deeper league and he is your current tight end. While it’s up for debate if he will be successful, let’s face the facts; Fitzpatrick will likely throw a ton. This is why I have Preston Williams as a FLEX/sleeper candidate this week. I even wrote about him in a QB List predictions piece last month. I believe he has the makings of a solid receiver, and even find the end zone in consecutive weeks this game. I would look for his target share to rise from the three he saw against Baltimore.

-Matthew Cava (@cavaM_)

72 responses to “Sit/Start Week 2: Reviewing All the Fantasy Relevant Players In Every Single Game”

  1. Michael Van Etten says:

    12 team ppr .5

    In my flex

    John Brown or Jamison Crowder

  2. Adam says:

    I see that you recommend sitting Robby. Would it be wise to start John Brown or Valdez-Scantling over him?

  3. Greg says:

    John Ross or Mark Andrews at the flex position? 12 team ppr

    • Erik Smith says:

      That’s a really interesting decision. I would normally always want the wide receiver, but I’m still a little hesitant to trust Ross, and Andrews has an excellent matchup against the Cardinals. I think I like Andrews, but it’s close.

  4. Jacob says:

    Marvin Jones or DK Metcalf for my WR2?

    • Erik Smith says:

      I would lean Marvin Jones. I don’t expect Lockett to only get 2 targets a week, so he could get more work at Metcalf’s expense.

  5. Harrison says:

    I know it’s unconventional, but I have Devonta Freeman in my flex. With his performance last week, should I bench him for Mark Andrews? I already have Kittle at TE and don’t really think I should ever bench him. I also have Lat Murray on the bench and Mike Williams (since he’s questionable I put Allen Robinson in there).

  6. Alec says:

    Having trouble deciding between Delanie Walker or Darren Waller for the TE spot this week. 8 man PPR league

  7. dean says:

    who should i start as my flex? 12 team 1PPR. john brown, christian kirk, dante pettis, or chris thompson? thanks in advance!

  8. Ricky says:

    12 team/ .25ppr

    Montgomery or A Robinson in my flex? Who will the bears lean on more?

  9. Jess says:

    I’ve got John Ross III and Marquise Brown. Debating on starting one of them over Will Fuller in my flex spot. But also feeling a bit weary of my WR2 Josh Gordon. Thoughts?

  10. Joe says:

    Hockenson or Waller? And
    Tyrell Williams or DJ Moore?
    1pt PPR

    • Frank Costanzo says:

      Hock and DJ for me

    • Kevin Taylor says:

      Definitely Waller over Hockenson for me. The game environment should be a lot better for throwing against the Chiefs. I see the Lions really slowing down and establishing the run against the Chargers, who also play at a slow pace.

      The other one is more of a toss-up. I think Moore is a better player and play normally but Thursday night games can get ugly. Williams has a great matchup and should have plenty of chances for volume against the Chiefs. Williams feels safer especially with Cam not looking great throwing the ball in week 1

  11. Colin says:

    Tyler Boyd or DJ Moore for my WR2?
    Aaron Jones or Marlon Mack for my Flex? Other two RBs are David Johnson and Chris Carons.

    10 man PPR league.

  12. Daniel Lunsford says:

    Who do I play?
    .5ppr
    10 team league
    3 wrs + 2rbs + 1 flex
    *Boyd/Keenan Allen/Diggs/DJ Moore
    *Bell/Sony Michelle/D. Williams/D. Johnson
    *Engram/Mark Andrews

    • Stephen Dudas says:

      D. Johnson
      Bell (if healthy watch for that)
      Allen
      Diggs
      Boyd
      Sony — I do not think we need to overreact to week 1! He still got the bulk of the carries

  13. Bruce says:

    Latavius Murray, Curtis Samuel, or Ronald Jones for Flex?

    .5 PPR league

    Thanks!

  14. Aaron says:

    Please help! Josh Gordan vs Miami or Evans vs Carolina? Who do I start

  15. Logan Ostrander says:

    Josh Gordan, Mike Evans, or John Brown. Need two, one for WR2 and the Other for FLEX.

  16. Pamela says:

    Looking for advice – 14 team PPR league
    2 WRs + 2 RB + 1 Flex
    D Adams/J Edelman/M Gallup/J Ross
    *J White/
    D Williams/C Thompson/M Breida

    note my current starters – should I make changes? I’m mostly torn between playing Gallup, Breida or Thompson

  17. joshua m heckroth says:

    Room for 3 WR- Stephon Diggs, Tyrell Williams, Larry Fitzgerald and Marquis Brown. Who sits?

  18. k c says:

    14 team non ppr stuck with Jameis as my QB, only other QBs on the wire are Keenum, Mariota, Minshew…. it’s a mess. Please help!

  19. Joe Maskery says:

    1pt ppr. need a RB and a Flex: Damien Williams, Marlon Mack, Holleywood Brown. which 2 would you start?

  20. Brendan Lemieux says:

    Lamar Jackson or Tom Brady (I’m leaning towards Brady, but the pats never do too hot against miami at miami)

  21. JOHN PHILLIPS says:

    Would this still be useful for a ten team, PPR ?
    Thanks

  22. Roberto says:

    12 Team Standard – Flex Chris Thompson or Latavius Murray?

    • Kevin Taylor says:

      In a standard league, it is Murray for me. This game has a big total and should be fantasy friendly all around, giving Murray a nice chance at a TD. Not getting Thompson’s receptions takes away a lot of his value.

  23. Ryan says:

    Looking for RB2 in 10 Team Standard – Duke Johnson Jr, Devin Singletary, Malcolm Brown or Ronald Jones II

  24. Aaron says:

    Have a difficult FLEX decision to make in a 12 team full-PPR. Chris Thompson, Christian Kirk, Curtis Samuel, or TJ Hockenson? My gut says Thompson, but it’s a tough one.

  25. Tony says:

    Austin Hooper (vs Eagles) or Darren Waller (vs Chiefs) this week?

  26. Evan says:

    12 team .5 ppr flex
    Pick 2
    MVS
    AJ Brown
    Terry McLaurin
    Robby Anderson
    Mecole Hardman
    Mark Andrew’s

    (If im lucky I can flex Mixon in for one of these but not sure if he will even be worth playing through injury)

  27. Michael E Davis Jr says:

    Ok, I’ve got only one questions… Carson Wentz or Dak Prescott? 10 team full PPR.

  28. Jose says:

    Pick 1 RB and 1 flex

    Devonta Freeman, Chris Thompson

    John Brown, John Ross, Terry McClaurin

  29. Mike says:

    8 team league so stacked options…

    Sit Evans for: Tyrell Williams, Lockett, Larry Fitz?

    Was strongly considering Tyrell just because it should be a shootout and he’s guaranteed the volume against a weak secondary.

  30. hector schmidt says:

    12 team PPR
    I have to pick one, who to start: James Crowder vs DJ Moore vs Cooper Kupp?

    thanks

  31. bm says:

    aaron jones or d freeman this week? RB2, full PPR thanks

  32. Ronnie says:

    Start Baker Mayfield or Derek Carr? 10 team Half PPR

  33. Pete says:

    10 team, full PPR:
    QB: Carson Wentz or Lamar Jackson? (I know, I have it rough)
    RB: Singletary, Duke Johnson, Damien Williams (I’m leaning Damien Williams)
    Flex: Josh Gordon or one of the RBs above? (I’m leaning Singletary)

  34. Michael says:

    12 team, Full PPR
    who to flex Aaron Jones, Allen Robinson, Devin Singletary or Michael Gallup

  35. Deb H says:

    Full point PPR need a flex:
    John Brown or Chris Thompson. Or, do I trust Mixon?

    Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.