Sit/Start Week 2: Reviewing All the Fantasy Relevant Players In Every Single Game

The QB List staff helps you make your sit/start decisions for every Week 2 game.

Bills at Giants

 

Game Info

Kickoff: Sunday, September 15th at 1:00 pm EST

Location: MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford, New Jersey

Betting Odds: NYG +2.5, 42.5 Total via Oddsshark

Network: CBS

Sleeper Spotlight: Cole Beasley

 

Buffalo Bills

 

Quarterbacks

  • Josh Allen (Start/QB2 fringe QB1)

 

Josh Allen got off to a slow start last week against the Jets. Many fantasy fans seem to be jumping ship already but I’m not so sure just yet. I wouldn’t blame you for looking towards the waiver wire; there are probably a few options (Matthew Stafford and Jacoby Brissett) in your league. I wouldn’t say it’s the worst-case scenario just yet. The Bills’ defense should be able to keep their offense in most games. Allen’s two interceptions were both pretty flukey and not entirely his fault. He started to look much better in the fourth quarter and I expect his play to continue getting better. He has a solid bounce-back matchup against a Giants defense that was in the bottom five last year. Also, don’t expect Allen to be the runner he was last year. He put up a respectable 3.8 yards per carry but the Bills will try to give most of the running work to Devin Singletary

 

Running Backs

  • Devin Singletary (Start/RB2)
  • Frank Gore (Sit)

 

Many fantasy players came away from last week’s game confused about the Bills backfield. Many thought Frank Gore was used way too often but he was utilized the same as we saw in the preseason; mainly for ground-and-pound short gain plays. The only way I’m interested in keeping Gore on my fantasy team is if he exclusively gets all goal-line work, and even then it’s not likely. The guy averaged 1.8 yards per carry to Devin Singletary’s 17.5. The Bills finally fed Singletary the ball in the second half and he quickly looked to be the real deal. Keep a close eye on your fantasy players’ matchups this week because Singletary could be a smart and sneaky play going up against an exploitable Giants defense. If Gore concerns you, don’t let him. He was on the field for 19 snaps compared to Singletary’s 45. 

 

Wide Receivers/ Tight Ends

  • John Brown (Start/FLEX fringe WR2)
  • Cole Beasley (Start/FLEX)
  • Tommy Sweeney (Sit)
  • Zay Jones (Sit)

 

John Brown had a great Week 1 against the Jets and should continue to be a serviceable receiver, especially against a bad Giants defense. Most fantasy players should be pleased if they drafted Brown as a FLEX receiver. After last week it’s hard to not just plug-and-play him. Josh Allen should continue to target him often as well. I’m personally pretty high on Cole Beasley against the Giants. Beasley was the second most targeted receiver on the Bills in Week 1. Josh Allen targeted him quite often during his preseason reps as well. Beasley should be a solid option if you are desperate for a last-second receiver fill-in. 

 

Zay Jones could continue to improve but I doubt he will suddenly become fantasy relevant overnight. He will probably have his “boom” week at some point but do you want to bet which week that will happen? I would only consider him in incredibly deep PPR leagues. It’s worth keeping an eye on Tommy Sweeney this week but it’s not likely he gets involved to the point of fantasy success.

 

New York Giants

 

Quarterbacks

  • Eli Manning (Sit)
  • Daniel Jones (Sit)

 

I can’t be the only fantasy football fan waiting for Eli Manning to lose this starting job, right? I mean, it’s got to be a matter of time at this point. Maybe I just want to see something new for the Giants. We know what Eli can do. He was the same Eli last week as he’s always been; good at times but rarely great. His Week 1 efforts were commendable but his game is lacking venom with all these screens and quick slants. He rarely throws the long ball anymore. I wouldn’t feel safe starting him against what seems to be an improved Buffalo defense. Not to mention, his replacement is waiting in the wings for that inevitable day Eli pisses off his coaches with a pathetic performance. 

 

That being said, Daniel Jones getting one drive at the very end of a huge loss doesn’t tell us much about his time frame for eventually becoming the Giants’ starting quarterback. Jones could be a solid dynasty stash but I can’t tell you any more about the guy than I could before Week 1. All he’s done since then and now is throw three passes and fumble the ball. 

 

Running Backs

  • Saquon Barkley (Start/RB1)
  • Wayne Gallman (Sit)

 

This has got to be the easiest paragraph I’ll write all day. Saquon Barkley is still the guy to own here and you’re going to start him because he’s Saquon friggin’ Barkley. The guy ripped off a 59-yard run on his first carry of the season. His stats were fine in Week 1 but I’m expecting those numbers to rise when this offense starts clicking. That time may not come right away against a solid Bills defense this week, but as I said, Barkley should still be automatically started in all leagues. Don’t worry about seeing Wayne Gallman in the box score last week, this is still Barkley’s backfield and he’s a must-start.

 

Wide Receivers/ Tight Ends

  • Evan Engram (Start/TE1)
  • Cody Latimer (Sit)
  • Sterling Shepard (Start/WR2)
  • Bennie Fowler (Sit)

 

It looks like all that Evan Engram offseason hype was justified. He had a great Week 1 and was the clear target leader. There are times he seems like Eli’s favorite receiver out there. If Engram can keep playing at that level he’s a must-start who could easily finish the season top-five among tight ends. Fantasy owners were likely a little bummed Sterling Shepard only got seven targets in Week 1. I wouldn’t worry too much though, he’s still the WR1 on this team. His ten PPR points last week is likely his floor and I’m expecting him to bounce back a bit this week. Just keep an eye on his concussion and don’t be surprised if the Bills defense caps his potential upside. 

 

I also wanted to quickly mention Cody Latimer and Bennie Fowler who both had pretty solid showings last week. I would keep an eye on them to see if one of the two emerges as Eli’s third option, but until that happens, they will likely remain fantasy irrelevant simply because it’s too hard to know who will be productive from week-to-week. 

-Ryan Kruse (@ryanpkruse)

72 responses to “Sit/Start Week 2: Reviewing All the Fantasy Relevant Players In Every Single Game”

  1. Michael Van Etten says:

    12 team ppr .5

    In my flex

    John Brown or Jamison Crowder

  2. Adam says:

    I see that you recommend sitting Robby. Would it be wise to start John Brown or Valdez-Scantling over him?

  3. Greg says:

    John Ross or Mark Andrews at the flex position? 12 team ppr

    • Erik Smith says:

      That’s a really interesting decision. I would normally always want the wide receiver, but I’m still a little hesitant to trust Ross, and Andrews has an excellent matchup against the Cardinals. I think I like Andrews, but it’s close.

  4. Jacob says:

    Marvin Jones or DK Metcalf for my WR2?

    • Erik Smith says:

      I would lean Marvin Jones. I don’t expect Lockett to only get 2 targets a week, so he could get more work at Metcalf’s expense.

  5. Harrison says:

    I know it’s unconventional, but I have Devonta Freeman in my flex. With his performance last week, should I bench him for Mark Andrews? I already have Kittle at TE and don’t really think I should ever bench him. I also have Lat Murray on the bench and Mike Williams (since he’s questionable I put Allen Robinson in there).

  6. Alec says:

    Having trouble deciding between Delanie Walker or Darren Waller for the TE spot this week. 8 man PPR league

  7. dean says:

    who should i start as my flex? 12 team 1PPR. john brown, christian kirk, dante pettis, or chris thompson? thanks in advance!

  8. Ricky says:

    12 team/ .25ppr

    Montgomery or A Robinson in my flex? Who will the bears lean on more?

  9. Jess says:

    I’ve got John Ross III and Marquise Brown. Debating on starting one of them over Will Fuller in my flex spot. But also feeling a bit weary of my WR2 Josh Gordon. Thoughts?

  10. Joe says:

    Hockenson or Waller? And
    Tyrell Williams or DJ Moore?
    1pt PPR

    • Frank Costanzo says:

      Hock and DJ for me

    • Kevin Taylor says:

      Definitely Waller over Hockenson for me. The game environment should be a lot better for throwing against the Chiefs. I see the Lions really slowing down and establishing the run against the Chargers, who also play at a slow pace.

      The other one is more of a toss-up. I think Moore is a better player and play normally but Thursday night games can get ugly. Williams has a great matchup and should have plenty of chances for volume against the Chiefs. Williams feels safer especially with Cam not looking great throwing the ball in week 1

  11. Colin says:

    Tyler Boyd or DJ Moore for my WR2?
    Aaron Jones or Marlon Mack for my Flex? Other two RBs are David Johnson and Chris Carons.

    10 man PPR league.

  12. Daniel Lunsford says:

    Who do I play?
    .5ppr
    10 team league
    3 wrs + 2rbs + 1 flex
    *Boyd/Keenan Allen/Diggs/DJ Moore
    *Bell/Sony Michelle/D. Williams/D. Johnson
    *Engram/Mark Andrews

    • Stephen Dudas says:

      D. Johnson
      Bell (if healthy watch for that)
      Allen
      Diggs
      Boyd
      Sony — I do not think we need to overreact to week 1! He still got the bulk of the carries

  13. Bruce says:

    Latavius Murray, Curtis Samuel, or Ronald Jones for Flex?

    .5 PPR league

    Thanks!

  14. Aaron says:

    Please help! Josh Gordan vs Miami or Evans vs Carolina? Who do I start

  15. Logan Ostrander says:

    Josh Gordan, Mike Evans, or John Brown. Need two, one for WR2 and the Other for FLEX.

  16. Pamela says:

    Looking for advice – 14 team PPR league
    2 WRs + 2 RB + 1 Flex
    D Adams/J Edelman/M Gallup/J Ross
    *J White/
    D Williams/C Thompson/M Breida

    note my current starters – should I make changes? I’m mostly torn between playing Gallup, Breida or Thompson

  17. joshua m heckroth says:

    Room for 3 WR- Stephon Diggs, Tyrell Williams, Larry Fitzgerald and Marquis Brown. Who sits?

  18. k c says:

    14 team non ppr stuck with Jameis as my QB, only other QBs on the wire are Keenum, Mariota, Minshew…. it’s a mess. Please help!

  19. Joe Maskery says:

    1pt ppr. need a RB and a Flex: Damien Williams, Marlon Mack, Holleywood Brown. which 2 would you start?

  20. Brendan Lemieux says:

    Lamar Jackson or Tom Brady (I’m leaning towards Brady, but the pats never do too hot against miami at miami)

  21. JOHN PHILLIPS says:

    Would this still be useful for a ten team, PPR ?
    Thanks

  22. Roberto says:

    12 Team Standard – Flex Chris Thompson or Latavius Murray?

    • Kevin Taylor says:

      In a standard league, it is Murray for me. This game has a big total and should be fantasy friendly all around, giving Murray a nice chance at a TD. Not getting Thompson’s receptions takes away a lot of his value.

  23. Ryan says:

    Looking for RB2 in 10 Team Standard – Duke Johnson Jr, Devin Singletary, Malcolm Brown or Ronald Jones II

  24. Aaron says:

    Have a difficult FLEX decision to make in a 12 team full-PPR. Chris Thompson, Christian Kirk, Curtis Samuel, or TJ Hockenson? My gut says Thompson, but it’s a tough one.

  25. Tony says:

    Austin Hooper (vs Eagles) or Darren Waller (vs Chiefs) this week?

  26. Evan says:

    12 team .5 ppr flex
    Pick 2
    MVS
    AJ Brown
    Terry McLaurin
    Robby Anderson
    Mecole Hardman
    Mark Andrew’s

    (If im lucky I can flex Mixon in for one of these but not sure if he will even be worth playing through injury)

  27. Michael E Davis Jr says:

    Ok, I’ve got only one questions… Carson Wentz or Dak Prescott? 10 team full PPR.

  28. Jose says:

    Pick 1 RB and 1 flex

    Devonta Freeman, Chris Thompson

    John Brown, John Ross, Terry McClaurin

  29. Mike says:

    8 team league so stacked options…

    Sit Evans for: Tyrell Williams, Lockett, Larry Fitz?

    Was strongly considering Tyrell just because it should be a shootout and he’s guaranteed the volume against a weak secondary.

  30. hector schmidt says:

    12 team PPR
    I have to pick one, who to start: James Crowder vs DJ Moore vs Cooper Kupp?

    thanks

  31. bm says:

    aaron jones or d freeman this week? RB2, full PPR thanks

  32. Ronnie says:

    Start Baker Mayfield or Derek Carr? 10 team Half PPR

  33. Pete says:

    10 team, full PPR:
    QB: Carson Wentz or Lamar Jackson? (I know, I have it rough)
    RB: Singletary, Duke Johnson, Damien Williams (I’m leaning Damien Williams)
    Flex: Josh Gordon or one of the RBs above? (I’m leaning Singletary)

  34. Michael says:

    12 team, Full PPR
    who to flex Aaron Jones, Allen Robinson, Devin Singletary or Michael Gallup

  35. Deb H says:

    Full point PPR need a flex:
    John Brown or Chris Thompson. Or, do I trust Mixon?

    Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.