Miami Dolphins @ Indianapolis Colts
Final Score: Colts 24, Dolphins 22
Writer: Steven Pintado (@coachstevenp)
Three Up
- Malik Washington — There weren’t many positives in this game, but Washington put together a solid performance and even threw a passing touchdown.
- Seth McGowan — Many expected McGowan to disappear with Jonathan Taylor staying a Colt, but he remained heavily involved in the offense. In a close game, McGowan continued to see a steady workload and kept pace with Taylor in touches for much of the contest.
- Caleb Douglas — Douglas got off to a slow start but eventually became a key part of the passing offense. He saw plenty of targets and finished as the team’s leading receiver in yardage.
Three Down
- Jonathan Taylor — Yes, Taylor finished with 18 total touches and solid yardage, but losing goal-line opportunities and overall touches to McGowan is concerning.
- Tyler Warren — With the lack of talent among the Colts’ pass catchers, Warren was expected to step up and play a bigger role in the passing game. Instead, he finished with just three targets in a disappointing performance.
- Daniel Jones — The Colts quarterback looked like he was doing everything possible to give this game away. Indianapolis didn’t rely heavily on Jones in the offense, limiting his opportunities to make an impact.
Miami Dolphins
Quarterback
Kyle McCord: 17/32, 209 Yards| 2 carries, 4 Yards, TD, Fumble (Lost)
McCord made his first start of the season and it was an uneven performance. On the positive side, McCord settled down after a slow start and made some nice throws in the second and third quarters. When he had time in the pocket or was able to roll out and extend plays, he showed the ability to make accurate throws downfield. One of his best plays came on a deep pass to Caleb Douglas in the third quarter. McCord was willing to take shots downfield, something we didn’t see nearly enough of with Malik Willis under center. He also managed to find the end zone with his legs, adding a rushing touchdown to his performance.
However, there were plenty of negatives as well. McCord struggled to get going early, relying too heavily on dump-off passes rather than pushing the ball downfield. He also had several passes batted down at the line of scrimmage, including some in critical situations late in the game. His biggest mistake came on a costly fumble in the end zone that resulted in a Colts touchdown. McCord also had a few questionable throws that could have easily turned into interceptions. While he showed flashes of potential and a willingness to attack downfield, there wasn’t enough consistency to suggest he’ll significantly elevate Miami’s passing offense.
Running Back
Ollie Gordon II: 20 Carries, 76 Yards | 5 Targets, 4 Receptions, 39 Yards
Gordon had another uneven performance against the Colts. He continued to dominate the backfield workload but struggled with efficiency, averaging just 3.8 yards per carry. Gordon did break off a couple of nice runs in the 2nd quarter that helped Miami get into scoring position, but his biggest impact came in the passing game. He was effective on dump-off passes, using his physicality to fight through defenders and pick up additional yards after the catch. While his rushing efficiency remains a concern, the volume continues to be there, which is what matters most for fantasy.
Kaytron Allen: 1 Carry, 0 Yards | 1 Target, 1 Reception, -4 Yards
Jaylen Wright: 3 Carries, -2 Yards | 2 Targets, 2 Receptions, 17 Yards
DJ Herman: 1 Target, 1 Reception, 10 Yards
Wide Receiver/Tight End
Malik Washington: 3 Targets, 3 Receptions, 50 Yards | 1/1, 34 Yards, TD
The Dolphins’ WR1 put together a solid performance in this game, highlighted by one of the coolest plays of the day. In the second quarter, Washington executed a trick play perfectly, throwing a 34-yard touchdown pass to a wide-open Jalen Tolbert. As a receiver, Washington made a few solid catches in the second quarter before nearly pulling off an impressive one-handed catch over a defender early in the third quarter. However, he wasn’t targeted again for the remainder of the game. It seemed like Miami shifted its offensive approach in the second half, focusing more on pushing the ball downfield and establishing the running game rather than relying on the short, quick passes that typically benefit Washington.
Caleb Douglas: 8 Targets, 3 Receptions, 71 Yards
The rookie got off to a slow start, seeing just one target in the first half. He wouldn’t see another target until midway through the 3rd quarter, but from that point on, Douglas became a focal point of the passing game, seeing seven targets over the remainder of the contest. He made several impressive catches, including a 38-yard gain downfield with a defender all over him. Douglas also hauled in a terrific 22-yard reception where he had to leap up to secure the ball. It almost seemed like Douglas preferred making difficult catches over easy ones, as he dropped a wide-open pass over the middle that would have gone for 15 yards. What stood out most was McCord’s willingness to target Douglas late in the game. That’s an encouraging sign for his fantasy outlook, especially with Miami likely to be playing from behind frequently throughout the rest of the season.
Jalen Tolbert: 2 Targets, 2 Receptions, 49 Yards, TD
Tolbert caught a wide-open 34-yard touchdown pass late in the second quarter on a trick play designed by the Dolphins. Miami caught the defense completely off-guard, allowing Tolbert to get open for an easy touchdown.
Kevin Coleman Jr.: 6 Targets, 1 Reception, 6 Yards
Will Kacmarek: 1 Target, 1 Reception, 5 Yards
Greg Dulcich: 2 Targets
Jalen Reagor: 1 Target
Indianapolis Colts
Quarterback
Daniel Jones: 17/25, 108 Yards, TD, 2 INTs | 4 Carries, 5 Yards
Jones had a rough day, averaging just 4.9 yards per completion. Yes, Jones threw an accurate short touchdown pass to Laquon Treadwell, but outside of that play, he struggled throughout the game. Jones finished with two interceptions, although one wasn’t entirely his fault, as a difficult catch bounced off his receiver and into the hands of a defender, who returned it for a touchdown. He also got lucky on a few other plays that could have resulted in turnovers, including another potential interception and a fumble. Jones wasn’t given much time to throw, forcing him to rely heavily on short passes rather than taking shots downfield. With a positive game script, the Colts leaned on their running game as much as possible, limiting Jones’ opportunities.
Running Back
Jonathan Taylor: 16 Carries, 83 Yards| 4 Targets, 2 Receptions, 20 Yards
Taylor was solid in this game, averaging 5.2 yards per carry while remaining involved in the passing game. He had at least four runs of 10-plus yards, including a 17-yard gain in the third quarter that was his longest run of the day. Taylor also served as a reliable dump-off option for Jones throughout the game. However, what concerns me most is how close Seth McGowan finished to Taylor in total carries. Taylor also lost valuable red-zone opportunities to McGowan, which could significantly impact his elite fantasy upside moving forward. It’s possible there’s more to Taylor’s usage, whether he’s dealing with an undisclosed injury or the Colts are simply being cautious with his workload. Whatever the reason, if this backfield rotation continues, it’s going to be difficult to trust Taylor as an elite RB1 in fantasy.
Seth McGowan: 12 Carries, 77 Yards, TD
McGowan ran well, showing some explosiveness with a 23-yard run, the longest of any Colts running back. That big gain helped set up a short rushing touchdown for McGowan just a few plays later. What stood out most was how frequently McGowan and Taylor rotated throughout the game. It seemed like every few plays, one running back would come off the field for the other. McGowan wasn’t just getting touches late in the game, either, as he was involved as early as the Colts’ second offensive drive. That’s something worth monitoring, especially for Taylor’s fantasy value moving forward. However, it’s difficult to know whether this rotation will continue, considering this was a favorable matchup for the Colts’ backfield.
Wide Receiver/Tight End
Ashton Dulin: 1 Target, 1 Reception, 30 Yards
In the second quarter, Dulin caught a short slant pass and exploded for a 30-yard gain. Dulin has the explosiveness to turn short receptions into big plays, but he remains a very boom-or-bust receiver in fantasy.
Tyler Warren: 3 Targets, 2 Receptions, 1 Yards | 1 Carry, 3 Yards
Warren didn’t see his first target until early in the third quarter and didn’t record his first reception until late in the quarter. Most of his opportunities came near the line of scrimmage on dump-off passes, limiting his ability to make an impact. He did have an 11-yard reception called back due to a penalty, but there were also several plays where Warren appeared to be open and simply wasn’t targeted. The Colts clearly didn’t game plan to make Warren a focal point of the passing offense, which is concerning given the lack of proven receiving talent around him.
Laqoun Treadwell: 3 Targets, 3 Receptions, 24 Yards, TD
Treadwell has been one of the more consistent options in the Colts’ passing offense since Alec Pierce went down. Treadwell scored a touchdown late in the second quarter and added a few catches before halftime. However, he didn’t see another target for the remainder of the game. The Colts continue to spread the ball around, making it difficult to trust any of these receivers in fantasy. Whether it’s Treadwell, Anthony Gould, or Ashton Dulin, none have established themselves as reliable fantasy options. We need to see more consistency and a clearer target distribution before trusting any of them in starting lineups.
Anthony Gould: 4 Targets, 2 Receptions, 28 Yards
Drew Ogletree: 2 Targets, 1 Reception, 5 Yards
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine: 1 Target
Deion Burks: 2 Targets