Sit/Start 2025 Week 18: Reviewing All Fantasy Relevant Players in Every Game

Sit or Start recommendations for EVERY fantasy-relevant player in Week 18 of the 2025 NFL season!

Game Info

 

Kickoff: Sunday, January 4, 2026, 4:25 p.m. ET

Location: Highmark Stadium, Orchard Park, NY

Network: CBS

 

New York Jets

 

Quarterback

Brady Cook: SIT

Brady Cook has one touchdown pass in four starts.

 

Running Back

Breece Hall: START, RB2

Breece Hall left the game against New England with a knee injury, but it wasn’t considered a serious issue postgame. Hall started off the week not practicing, but was able to return to a limited practice Thursday. If he’s able to start Sunday, he’s an RB2 in a fantastic matchup against the Bills, but his potential to leave early if his knee flares up prevents me from putting him in the top 12.

 

Wide Receiver | Tight End

Adonai Mitchell: SIT
John Metchie III: SIT
Isaiah Williams: SIT
Whoever starts at TE: SIT

Adonai Mitchell has more targets (15) than fantasy points (12.5) in his last two games. No Jets pass catcher is startable with Cook under center.

 

Defense/Special Teams

New York Jets: SIT

 

Buffalo Bills

 

Quarterback

Josh Allen: SIT
Mitchell Trubisky: SIT, QB2 (startable in Superflex)

It has yet to be officially announced if Josh Allen will start Sunday. But even if he does, there is zero chance he plays the whole game. If Allen is inactive, Mitchell Trubisky can serve as a desperation (and I mean DESPERATION) start in Superflex, given how the Jets’ defense is. It has allowed 12 touchdowns to quarterbacks in their last three games.

 

Running Back | Wide Receiver | Tight End

James Cook III: SIT
Ty Johnson: SIT
Ray Davis: SIT
Joshua Palmer: SIT
Tyrell Shavers: SIT
Khalil Shakir: SIT
Dawson Knox: SIT

The Bills are locked into a wild-card spot and don’t gain much in terms of finishing as the No. 5, 6 or 7 seed. So it’s more than probable that any starters who do play are off the field before the third quarter. Avoid all of Buffalo’s skill-position players in Week 18. 

 

Defense/Special Teams

Buffalo Bills: START

Last game in their stadium against a Cook-led Jets team? Yes, please.