Sit/Start 2025 Week 10: Reviewing All Fantasy Relevant Players in Every Game

Sit or Start recommendations for EVERY fantasy-relevant player in Week 10 of the 2025 NFL season!

Game Info

 

Kickoff: Sunday, November 9, 2025, 1:00 PM ET

Location: Soldier Field, Chicago, IL

Network: FOX

 

New York Giants

 

Quarterback

Jaxson Dart: START, QB1

Jaxson Dart threw for under 200 passing yards for the third time in his last four, but that doesn’t really matter when you have a rushing touchdown in nearly every game. The rookie had his fourth straight game with a rushing touchdown, his fifth in his last six games, and his second straight start without a turnover. Dart completed 73% of his passes, but that number is a bit deceiving, considering 60% of his pass attempts were under 10 yards. His rushing prowess gives him a nice, safe floor, and while his ceiling isn’t quite what it could be with a healthy Malik Nabers and Cam Skattebo, it’s still high enough to consider him a top 12 option. I was hesitant to start him in 1QB, but Dart proved to me that he’s a must-start in all formats for the remainder of the season. Facing a Bears defense that just gave up four touchdowns and nearly 500 passing yards to 40-year-old Joe Flacco, Dart is pushing close to the Top 5 for Week 10.

 

Running Back

Tyrone Tracy Jr.: BORDERLINE FLEX
Devin Singletary: BORDERLINE FLEX

Well, we thought it would be the Tyrone Tracy show when Cam Skattebo went down, but it was Devin Singletary who led the way for the Giants on the ground. Singletary handled 38.1% of the rush attempts in Week 9 compared to 23.8% for Tracy, and the former outsnapped the latter 55.4% to 44.6%. If you’re in a pinch and need one, I’d actually advise Singletary. Chicago is allowing a 57.1% success rate in man/gap runs, with Singletary sporting a 60% success rate in the concept to Tracy’s 42%. But I’d much prefer to avoid the entire situation until if/when one of the two closes to ~50% of carries. Both are essentially unstartable.

 

Wide Receiver

Wan’Dale Robinson: START, WR3
Darius Slayton: FLEX, WR4

Wan’Dale Robinson maintains one of the safest floors in fantasy, averaging over eight targets and close to six catches per game since the Giants lost Nabers for the season. In the three games Darius Slayton has played in since Nabers went down, Slayton leads the team in deep targets and air yards share, and dropped what could have been Dart’s 3rd passing touchdown against the 49ers in the endzone. To be fair, Slayton took a big hit and left the game with an injury, but it appeared he could have come down with the catch. He’s expected to suit up versus Chicago, a team that gives up an average of 68 yards per game on downfield pass attempts, second most to Dallas. The Bears have bled fantasy points to receivers this season, allowing the second most, and coming off a game against where three different Cincy receivers scored over 14 fantasy points. Robinson is the safer play, but Slayton has the ceiling.  

 

Tight End

Theo Johnson: STREAMER

Since Jaxson Dart became the Giants’ starter, 50% of the Giants’ receiving touchdowns have gone to Theo Johnson. The second-year tight end also has the most targets inside the 20 (6) and endzone (3) over that timeframe. The Bears are a middle-of-the-road matchup for tight ends, but have given up a touchdown to the position in three of their last four games. He’s a solid streamer you’re hoping comes down with a touchdown.

 

Defense/Special Teams

New York Giants: SIT

New York has allowed the fifth most points per game this season (27.7), and the third most over their last three (35). 

 

Chicago Bears

 

Quarterback

Caleb Williams: START, QB1

Caleb Williams wasn’t half bad himself, tallying four total touchdowns, three passing TDs, and one receiving TD. Yes, you heard that right, a receiving touchdown on a trick play, a double reverse on fourth down that ended with a strike from DJ Moore in the first quarter. Williams went 20/34, 280 yards, and chipped in 53 rushing yards on five carries. His sub 60% completion percentage isn’t ideal, but these types of ceiling games are what I imagined he was capable of with the flashes of brilliance we’ve seen from Williams this season. His Week 9 performance was a massive step in the right direction in our ability to trust him on a weekly basis. I’m not ready to declare Williams an every-week start regardless of matchup just yet. He’s going to be inconsistent at times, but the Giants are a dream matchup. New York has given up 10 touchdowns to quarterbacks over their last three games and allow the seventh most points to the position. 

 

Running Back

D’Andre Swift: START, RB1*Monitor practice reports*
Kyle Monangai: FLEX, RB3 (If Swift Active) | START, RB2 (If Swift Inactive)

There’s no word if D’Andre Swift will return in Week 10. If he does, he’s an automatic start in a top-five fantasy matchup against the Giants. But in his absence, Kyle Monangai was a MONSTER against the Bengals, bearing the rock 26 times for 176 yards, averaging a ridiculous 6.4 yards per carry. The rookie added three catches for 22 yards and totaled 22.8 fantasy points without scoring a single touchdown. As long as Swift is out, Monangai is easily a high-upside RB2. Even when Swift returns, Monangai has shown enough to be considered a volatile but high-ceiling FLEX play.

 

Wide Receiver

Rome Odunze: START, WR1
DJ Moore: START, WR3
Olamide Zaccheaus: BORDERLINE FLEX

Rome O., Rome O., where art thou fantasy points? Yeah, I know that was awful, but so was Rome Odunze in Week 9. He had three targets, zero catches, zero fantasy points, and scored under five fantasy points in three of his last four games. You obviously aren’t benching Odunze, but the floor we enjoyed early this season is, in the words of N*Sync, “Gone“. He’s in a perfect “get right” spot against the Giants. DJ Moore scored twice against the Bengals, but he didn’t catch a touchdown.

He threw one

and rushed for one.

You clearly can’t rely on those types of touchdowns, but it’s a positive sign that Ben Johnson continues to use Moore in a variety of ways. He’s a volatile WR3. Olamide Zaccheaus has back-to-back games of seven targets, six catches, and double-digit fantasy points. If you’re desperate for a dart-throw FLEX, you could do worse than Zaccheaus in this phenomenal matchup. 

 

Tight End

Colston Loveland: START, TE1
Cole Kmet: SIT *Could Miss Week 10*

 The first tight end taken in the 2025 NFL draft had the best game of his short career in Week 9 with six catches on seven targets, 118 yards, and two touchdowns. One of which was the game-winner.

Loveland’s breakout game coming against the Bengals isn’t a surprise, considering they’ve allowed the most fantasy points to the position. But one thing to consider is that this performance did come with Cole Kmet sidelined. Kmet started the game but left the game with four minutes left in the second quarter after suffering a concussion. At that point, Loveland had just two catches for 14 yards. I’m not saying you shouldn’t buy into the breakout game, but it is interesting. There’s no official word at the time of writing, but I’d expect Kmet to miss at least one game, but even if he doesn’t, Loveland is a must-start tight end for Week 10. 

 

Defense/Special Teams

Chicago Bears: SIT

Did you see what this defense let 40-year-old Joe Flacco do with a bum shoulder?